The Condemned City and the Challenge of Interpretation
In Eliezer Berkovits and Parashat Re'eh by Calev Ben-Dor
What should we do when a command in the Torah appears to conflict with the Torah’s own deepest moral values?
Faced with the law of the condemned city, the sages offered radically different answers. Some defended the command as written. Others protested its injustice, restricted it until it became nearly impossible to carry out, or interpreted it so boldly that they concluded it had never happened at all.
Their debate reaches far beyond one troubling biblical law. It asks whether faithfulness means obeying the text as it stands—or accepting responsibility for where our interpretation may lead.